Royall M. Mack Sr., who Gov. Deval Patrick appointed chairman of the Middlesex Community College board of trustees two years ago, has “bragged” for more than 10 years that he has an “executive MBA from Harvard University.” However, The Boston Herald reported Tuesday that the Ivy League school does not award that degree.
On the 11-year-old website of his corporation, Ciara Enterprises LLC, Mack Sr. has recorded that he received the graduate degree through the school’s Advanced Management Program. Yet, the program lasts eight weeks and awards only an official recognition for a current price of about $75,000. Furthermore, none of the Harvard Business School program has ever offered an “Executive MBA.”
In a Press Release dated Oct. 19, 2012, “GOVERNOR PATRICK APPOINTS ROYALL M. MACK, SR. AS CHAIR OF MIDDLESEX COMMUNITY COLLEGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES,” the governor said, “He earned a Bachelor of Science degree from North Carolina Agricultural & Technical State University, and graduated first in his class from Harvard University’s Advanced Management Program.”
“The class voted on the person that best represented the class,” Mack told the Herald. “That’s basically how it was positioned. … The classmates had to vote on it. It’s a very intense senior-level program.”
Mack said that his failure to accurate the website was an “honest mistake.” However, on his website, the error had not been fixed (as of Dec. 10).
Patrick’s headquarters didn’t respond to precise inquiries about Mack. In its place, the governor released a statement saying all chairman nominations are handled through the Public Education Nominating Council before an endorsement is made to the governor.
On Dec. 10, the governor promised to “get the facts from the source,” while affirming that he does not have conversations with “individual appointees to community college boards (in advance).”
The same day, Mack sent the following email to all MCC students, trustees, and employees:
“I want to take this opportunity to address an allegation that has surfaced this week regarding the misrepresentation of my academic credentials. Media reports this week have called into question the authenticity of my academic achievements from Harvard University. I want to make it clear that I attended the Harvard University Graduate School of Business Administration in 1991 and successfully completed the 109th session of their Advanced Management Program.
At no time have I personally represented that I obtained an executive MBA from Harvard as a result. That information was gleaned by a web page designer, from a completion certificate I received from Harvard. The web designer misinterpreted that information and included it in web-based biographies that were included on several websites as well as announcements from the Commonwealth of Massachusetts related to my appointment as chair of the Middlesex Community College Board of Trustees.
This clarification has been communicated to the Commissioner of Higher Education in Massachusetts.
I want to assure all of you that I place the highest possible value on personal integrity and would never intentionally misrepresent such an academic achievement, and in no way whatsoever should this reflect at all on any of the outstanding work being performed by the MCC Board of Trustees nor any of the college’s staff, faculty, or students.”
As the Middlesex board gathered to name President Carole Cowan’s replacement on Dec 11, Cowan and other trustees said they have confidence in Mack regardless of the reports. Trustee Paul E. Means, a former state representative from Stoneham, said the chairman had been “beaten up in the press” but that he did a “very good job” in guiding the search for a new president; however, “The appearance stretches the credibility that person has when something like this happens,” said Means.
Cowan, in a brief interview, told a Herald reporter that “you’d have to talk to (Mack)” and said his inflated resume doesn’t concern her. “Full confidence,” she said of him.
UPDATE: Dec. 12
In a three-paragraph resignation letter sent to the governor on Dec 12, Mack says that he quits with “great regret and inestimable pride” in MCC. Just a day before, Mack chaired the board’s final meeting of the year, where they selected James Mabry as MCC new president, replacing the outgoing Carole Cowan, who is leaving her $260,000-a-year post after more than 20 years.